SITE RATING: 7/10
SITE
REVIEW: This
performance, independently released by The
Piedmont Baroque Consortium, is an abridged
document - featuring Part One of Messiah
along with a "bonus" chorus of "Hallelujah"
(since it can't be Messiah without
its most famous chorus, can it?) and
features some very nice moments, with some
sterling performances by select soloists and
orchestra, raising it a bit above most
regional recordings. I found superior
tones and performances by tenor John
Kaneklides, who I found particularly
winning, alto Martha Bartz, bass Neal Sharpe and soprano
Jennifer Ellis-Kampani. Alto Reginald
Mobley presents a rather piercing vibrato
which fluttered and swooped in a distracting
manner, and which I found too strident
within the fabric of the majority of the
soloists. The combined baroque
orchestras play admirably - a credit to both
them and conductor David Tang, who leads
everything with a sure hand. The
chorus is a little distant in the mix - with
a generally clear, white tone, only with
occasional sections (I'm looking at you,
tenors) leaping out of the blend.
Nothing struck me as particularly
electrifying, but this is a very polished,
professional group, which any community
would be proud to call their own.
|