SITE RATING: 4/10
SITE
REVIEW:
A
very brief "highlights" LP from 1972, Douglas
Gamley's stolid direction
manages to get the job done, but the added
orchestration (is that a
pair of oboes bursting out during the
Overture?) and generally listless
performance by the London Philharmonic doesn't
inspire much affection.
Tenor Ian Calley posesses a smooth,
creamy texture and sure pitch
in his tone, both of which I found beguiling,
even with his overcooked
rolled "R's" which vibrate enough to cut down
trees. The London
Philharmonic Chorus are the weakest member of
the combined forces, with
strident, Wagnerian attacks, and a poor, muddy
mix which heavily favors
the disunified altos and diminishes the
sopranos to a distracting
degree. Soprano Norma Burrowes sounds
very young on "I Know That
My Redeemer Liveth", even younger than her
then twenty-eight years of
age, with a bright, bird-like tone which
hasn't matured into it's full
bloom yet. Other than the two soloists,
and their single numbers,
I couldn't find much to recommend about this
deservedly out-of-print
recording, with generally leaden tempos,
heavily blocked singing, muddy
sound, and a strident attitude by the chorus
that relegates this LP to
the lower end of Messiah
recordings.
|