SITE RATING: 6/10
SITE
REVIEW:
A privately issued recording, this 1995
selection of highlights
by The Covenant Presbyterian Church in
Nashville, Tennessee under the
direction of David Dunham has some striking
performances which caught
my ear. First, the recording is live,
and not as immediate in its
sound as I would like; there is intermittent
audience noise, but not a
distracting amount. Dunham utilizes three
sopranos for this
performance, and despite notes on individual
choir and orchestra
members, as well as the text for the pieces
included, there is no
listing of which Soprano soloist sings which
aria, which I found
strange. The orchestra is very good,
playing with excellent tone
and unity, and the Chancel Choir is similarly
very good, not
professional class, but not the
run-of-the-mill amateur choir either -
obviously an auditioned choir, with good blend
and tone. The high
standard of the players and singers lift this
recording up above other
privately-released albums. But what
caught my ear particularly
was alto soloist Vicki Sells, who gives one of
the most impassioned
readings of "He Was Despised" that I've ever
heard - the raw emotion
caught in her performance is worth hearing,
even if not performed in a
strict "baroque" or even "classical" sense.
The soprano soloists
are all very good, and I wish I could
distinguish which soprano sang
what. Tenor Chris McKim is the weak link
here, with a tremulous
and thin outing on "Thy rebuke hath broken His
heart" and "He was cut
off" - although part of the problem may be
that he sounds more distant
in the mix. The album features only two
long tracks, with the
first six cuts strung together, and the final
five making up the second
track. Still, for such a short album, I
was happy to hear it, in
only for Vicki Sells searing "He was
despised".
|